"If you are trying to create art around this topic then you have to be considering these issues of consent and re-traumatization. Williams didnt want the level of comfort that had been established with Smyth to be disturbed by any unfamiliar faces. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. According to Best's lawsuit, the above (legally made*) secret recording of a December 30, 2013 telephone call with retired OPP Detective Sergeant Jim Van Allen confirms that Van Allen was a serving police officer in charge of the Ontario Provincial Police elite Criminal Profiling Unit when in October 2009 he illegally investigated Donald Best . She viewed him as pretty useless and just a placement, and both police and Mr. Armishaw believed she was still in a sexual relationship with Jaydins father. . Perry said you can see the growing discomfort registering on Williams' face as he is confronted with more and more damning evidence. To most people, the answer was quite obvious. Ever been interviewed by the police in a room like this before? Smyth asked. . Some information may no longer be current. An image of the animal served as the wallpaper on the colonel's BlackBerry. Warning: This article contains sensitive material that may not be suitable for all audiences. Beginning in May 2008, a rash of similar crimes occurred in the vicinity of Williamss home in Orleans. Experienced Investigator with a demonstrated history of working in the law enforcement industry. CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices. [He then stopped writing and scribbled out the lines he had written.]. An artistic Special Olympics athlete recently honored an Iowa State Patrol officer who died in the line of duty with a drawing and letter. The investigation, Smyth said, involved fifty to sixty officers and would end up costing well over $10 million.[6]. There was a female police officer that actually drove by that location that evening and recalls seeing an SUV-type vehicle in the field. When prison officials told Simpson, "Don't come back," the former Buffalo Bills star responded, "I don't have any intent," according to Keast.. Smyth asked him about what kind of feelings he experienced with Jessica, having spent almost twenty-four hours together. . . Williams raped her and made her pose for photographs. Smyth is a behavioural specialist who earned great praise for his 2010 interrogation of Russell Williams, who during the course of the interrogationadmittedraping and strangling Jessica Lloyd and raping and suffocating Cpl. Interviews are conducted one-on-one, so there is no real or perceived ganging up to intimidate the suspect. The Ontario Crown announced Monday it will not appeal the Sept. 26 decision of Mr. Justice Kenneth A. Langdon that Det.-Sgt. The sketch showed a laneway across from a house set at a particular angle to the road, court has seen. Hidden behind the scenes, four officers were discreetly observing the video feed from an adjacent room. He is leaning forward, he's actually nodding in agreement with everything that's being said to him," he said. In those cases, conventional wisdom dictates that the interrogator should say little or nothing while the suspect stews. We were trying to gather information from Miss McClintic, again, assess her credibility. To Laurie Massicotte, his second sexual assault victim, he wrote: I am sorry for having hurt you the way I did. He mentions it on two or three occasions," said a source close to the investigation who has reviewed Col. William's detailed statement to police. Really? The pitch of Williamss voice rose as the word stretched from his lips. Use of this Website assumes acceptance of Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy | Accessibility, Published Friday, October 22, 2010 2:16PM EDT, Last Updated Saturday, May 19, 2012 3:00AM EDT, Taxpayers pick up cost of damage to Williams' home, Williams evidence should be destroyed, lawyer warns, After Williams trial, residents hold 'healing event', 'Sadosexual' killer Williams gets 2 life sentences, From the Archives: Fans celebrate Leafs 2004 playoff win, This globetrotter raises $300,000 for kids with disabilities, What you need to know about faded, peeling Ontario plates, CTV National News for Apr. The bizarre case shocked the military and the country and became an international media sensation. "Sgt. . In some cases he made return visits. Can I assume youre going to be discreet? he asked Smyth firmly, with the first hint of stress and irritation apparent in his voice. 3 February, he dumped Lloyds body in the woods near Tweed. 365 Bloor Street East, Toronto, Ontario, M4W 3L4. Thats a little microphone.. Ontario Provincial Police Det. Chief Instructor at Integrity Interviewing for Investigators Greater Toronto Area, Canada 974 followers 500+ connections Join to follow Integrity Interviewing for Investigators. What began as a fetish to steal womens undergarments grew into a compulsion to rape and murder. As a member of the notorious Dublin Castle G Division, he doggedly hunted. Eventually he began to take breaks from his seat, leaning against the wall for long periods of time. Ontario Provincial Police is part of the Government industry, and located in Canada. He used rational arguments to convince Williams that he had been caught. Access articles from across Canada with one account. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Earlier drafts to Mrs. Lloyd read as follows: I know you wont believe me but I am sorry for having taken your daughter from you. Top OPP interrogator credited with McClintic, Williams confessions | CBC News Loaded. Williams looked up at him, shook his hand, and then passively cast his eyes to the floor. When Detective-Sergeant Smyth returned to the interrogation room, Williams was sitting with his arms folded and his legs leisurely stretched out and crossed at the ankles. . [5], I know youre an intelligent person, and you probably dont need to hear this explanation, the detective said, stroking the colonels ego to win his favor. During the brief roadside interrogation, officers saw that the tread of Williamss tires matched those found in the field. She was enraged about the staged reading of the murderer's confession to OPP officer Jim Smyth and started a petition to stop the play, which about 2,000 people signed. "There's an awful lot of interviewing and skills and techniques that can be learned," said Ottawa police Sgt. The couple acquired Curio - the word means an unusual, and often fascinating, object of art - in the early 1990s, when Col. Williams was stationed in Portage La Prairie, Man., training up-and-coming pilots. Williams showed no interest and declined his offer. ., Well, you need to explain it, the detective told him as he prepared to unleash yet another shocking revelation to the already speechless commander. Police had just received information that directed them farther north than they had been searching, and on July 19, 2009, OPP Detective Staff Sergeant Jim Smyth decided to drive around the area of Mount Forest just to get an idea of the landscape. that contains our DNA. It was likely even he knew that. if, for whatever reason, you didnt end up on our radar so to speak, do you think it would have happened again?. That civilization was known to overwhelm and assimilate entire other civilizations; in stating its intent the Borg collective always announced: Resistance is futile.. Skilled in Government, Law Enforcement, Emergency Management, Conflict Resolution, and Presentation. Born in Britain, he had immigrated to Canada as a boy. Jim Smyth at Ottawa Police . Smyth began his career with the York Regional Police (in Ontario, Canada) in 1988 before joining the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) in 1997. . Jim Smith was a loving husband, father of two, and a pillar of the community. Smyth has also taught forensic interviewing and forensic behavioral science at Toronto's Seneca College. Smyth began his career with the York Regional Police in 1988 before joining the OPP in 1997, according to the Toronto Sun. ", While Seelig said he and the theatre company have responded to concerns like this, Dafoe said it's a "stockreply. I do hope that you find a way to succeed. Many people, such as journalist Michelle Lund, have commented that Smyth's soft-spoken interrogations are now textbook examples. Let me ask you this, Smyth continued. On February 7, Williams was interrogated by OPP investigator Detective Superintendent Jim Smyth and confronted with the evidence of tire tracks and boot prints at Lloyd's home. But sensing that relinquishing control would be a difficult step for the career military man who had been trained to remain tough and withstand intense interrogation tactics by enemy forces, he offered the colonel a concession. In one home, he had left a taunting message on a computer. Smyth lied to Mr. Armishaw about the evidence against him; engaged in a relentless monologue at a suspect who wished to remain silent; undermined Mr. Armishaws lawyers advice by suggesting the lawyer was ignorant of the overwhelming evidence against him; claimed to speak for the courts, and offered leniency in exchange for a confession; and placed a false choice before Mr. Armishaw confess or be damned in which innocence, though still technically presumed, was not an option. I was in Gatineau, as I said, meeting about the C-17., Okay, now if that is the day you had a meeting in Ottawa, do you remember being at the base on the Monday the twenty third and swiping your card in and out? The detective explained how his computers would be forensically analyzed and that no stone would be left unturned. [np-related]In his written reasons, Judge Langdons criticism of Det.-Sgt. If you are a Home delivery print subscriber, unlimited online access is, OPP detective used 'Reid technique' to get Russell Williams to confess, GARRIOCH: Billon dollar bid for Senators puts Reynolds and Remington Group in driver's seat, BUSTED: Cops arrest two, seize drugs and cash raid at Barrhaven residence, Katy Perry will be temporarily replaced by big-name star on 'American Idol', PSAC STRIKE: Union plans to bus in members to Ottawa for rally if deal not reached over the weekend, Public service union says weekend bargaining yields progress on wages, job security, tap here to see other videos from our team. Unauthorized distribution, transmission or republication strictly prohibited. . Williams listened to the officer intently, with furrowed brows and a tightly clenched jaw. The colonel raised his head, rubbed his neck, and looked his interrogator straight in the eyes. The proud military man would be certain to want to save face, contain the damage, and minimize the impact. Russell Williams is seen in this image taken from video of the OPP interview, released by the court in Belleville, Ont., Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2010. Tori's disappearance touched off a massive investigation in the spring of 2009, with nearly 1,000 officers involved at various points. Jim Smyth, M.O.M. Downs also praised Smyth for getting McClintic to draw maps of the scene where she said the killing took place. She did not know what was coming. Williams said he was in a hurry because he had a sick child at home. On the night of 23 November 2009, in Brighton, a town just west of Trenton, Williams broke into the home of Corporal Marie-France Comeau, who was under his command at CFB Trenton. Williams was married to Mary Elizabeth Harriman. Later they moved to a home they had built in the capitals Westboro neighbourhood. Jim Smyth, a veteran investigator, is the other man seen in the video. OPP Det. But he was wrong. When we find out whos responsible for one or all of those crimes, they could be charged. The detectives conversational-style questioning flip-flopped around with little apparent focus, often seeming to lack any specific direction or structure. Marie-France Comeau. Marie-France Comeau, along with 86 other charges. Over the hours that passed, Williams succumbed to both mental and physical distress. rights reserved. Audience Relations, CBC P.O. But now his sly charm and relentless. He was also registered as a sex offender. We try not to divulge any information we may have until we feel it becomes necessary, until essentially the interview turns into more of an interrogation.". Jim Smyth taking on Russell Williams in 2010. Our team will be reviewing your submission and get back to you with any further questions. "There are people behind these stories. "Its a science and an art," he said. Williams cast his eyes downward. 8-Wing TrentonThe official Air Force website for the Canadian Forces Base at Trenton, Ontario. This time when the officer returned, Williams had written a total of five apology letters (and three discarded drafts). "When the first piece of evidence was presented, (Williams) started to say: I don't understand' and all that," said Perry. It would then be only two days before hed be stopped and questioned by police at the fateful roadside canvass. Okay. Sgt. Itd be very boring.. Smyth then explained the reasons that police had focused their attention on him: the obvious geographical connections with three of the women and his military relationship with Comeau. He then stumbled over the pronunciation of their names and forgot the order in which the crimes occurred. Jim Szarka; 43; goes to school when he isn't pursuing major fraud investigations. Loran Chaptis attended a house on Concession 13, Snowdon Township, Haliburton County. Mendelson said it's a moment where Williams realizes he has "nowhere to go. The couple, who were childless, lived for 13 years in a house on Wilkie Drive in the. [5] The detectives response was not in keeping with standard protocol for dealing with a suspect who, like Williams, displays body language that suggests a confession is imminent. I had a realty lawyer, Williams chuckled, but, no, I dont have a lawyer.. In July 2009, on instinct, he searched arural roadnear Mount Forest, Ont., and found the remains of eight-year-old Victoria, who disappeared more than three months earlier. The video showing the interrogation of convicted sex killer Russell Williams is a window into the way skilled investigators use psychology to extract confessions, experts say. Smyth walked to a large evergreen tree behind the rock pile, pulled back some branches hanging very low to the ground and saw some rocks, he testified. Detective-Sergeant Smyth provided him with a pad of paper and a pen and suggested that he write some letters of apology to his victims, another common tactic used by police to avoid later allegations of a false confession. On the night of 2. He no longer looked the part of the confident, self-assured, gum-smacking military officer who had entered the room three hours earlier. If theres anything that comes up in our interview today, Russell, that you feel you want to talk to a lawyer about, you just let me know.. But thepsychologist isso bothered by the 90-production, scheduled to run March 3-12, she has decided to hand out pamphlets to theatre-goers on opening night tonight to remind them of the victims. What do four of the world's top body language, behavior, and interrogation experts want to know from Ontario Provincial Police Detective Superintendent Jim Smyth? . to colleagues, clients or customers, or inquire about Cpl. "Its great evidence," he said. After 10 years of front line policing. . ), Monterey Park, CA Police Department FBINA 214th Session Member - International Association of Chiefs of Police, Police Investigative Operations Committee Email: Jim.Smith@ecoatm.com Whats the option? the colonel replied, anxious to develop his strategy. Cause its tough to undo the rumor mill once it gets started. Colonel Williams sniffled. In July 2009, Colonel Russell Williams, 46, became commanding officer of 8 Wing CFB Trenton. This is one for the history books, in terms of a police interrogation.". Comeau was also a member of the Canadian Forces who worked on the same base as Williams. Sources close to the investigation scoff at the idea that the cat was a possible trigger - and not merely because it sounds so absurd, but more so because it can't be squared with the chronology of Col. William's dark descent; Curio's death took place more than a year after Col. Williams began his string of lingerie thefts. Cause you know this would have a very significant impact on the base if they thought you thought I did this.. Disappointed, Williams replied quietly. Williams victimized families whose members included girls or young women, entering residences at night when the people were away. Later they moved to a home they had built in the capitals Westboro neighbourhood. News of Williamss arrest and his bizarre double-life stunned everyone who knew him and shocked the public. He was introduced to Detective-Sergeant Jim Smyth, a forty-something, slightly bookish, unassuming officer in a dark suit and tie. The fact that Smyth calls him "Russell" is significant, said Mendelson, because it puts the detective and Williams on an even playing field. Cause Ive sat across from a lot of people in your position over the years.. Simpson is in a . Instructors have been referencing the techniques used to elicit a confession from Williams extensively in their classes and workshops. Your vehicle drove up the side of Jessica Lloyds house. Dafoe, who has a photo of Lloyd in her bedroom, said Smyth reached out to her after he saw her online petition and until then she hadn't thought about the investigator. .. It was behind that rock pile and underneath an evergreen tree that police would find Tori Stafford, she said. . Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. And they are absolutely not considering these whatsoever," Dafoe said. A Sergeant at Ontario Provincial Police Ed Johnson is a Sergeant at Ontario Provincial Police based in Orillia, Ontario. and probably a lot of other peoples DNA., Smyth continued, As we talk, you know a little bit of saliva comes out of our mouths. And essentially with footwear impressions, youre in a situation where youre pretty much in the area of fingerprints.. The stern expression on Williamss face and his folded arms revealed the mixed bag of emotions he felt as he was told that the case managers refused to pull any punches. Three new, buzzed-about beauty products we tried this week. Had he been there at any time? "They begin circling in and in and in it was a fascinating thing to watch," said CBC reporter Dave Seglins. Yeah, he muttered. As a production about the murders of Jessica Lloyd and Cpl. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. As he pushed the colonel for details about his abduction of Jessica, the detectives questioning sank to the depths of absurdity when he asked Williams to explain what he meant when he said that Lloyd had been cooperative. December 11th, 1968. Because Williams pleaded guilty to all charges, he was not put on trial. Smyth has also taught forensic interviewing and forensic behavioural science at Toronto's Seneca College. Again Williams shook his head and shrugged. Circumstances. Smyth is biting, even to the point of doubting the honesty of his testimony under oath. The confessionof Williams was by all accounts expertly coaxed the work of a whip-smart detective who was unyielding in an interrogation that ran 10 hours. I am persuaded that Mr. Armishaws will was overcome. Smyth did not know the area well, but as he passed a house at a particular angle to the road, across from a laneway, he got a sense he was in familiar territory. Age: 43. Less than five hours after he had driven to police headquarters in the same SUV he had used to abduct Jessica Lloyd and strode into the interview room wearing the same boots that he had used the night of her attack, the truth had finally surfaced. Jim Smyth joined York Regional Police in 1989. To Jane Doe, his first sexual assault victim, he wrote: I apologize for having traumatized you the way I did. They examined those tire tracks, and they have contacts in the tire business, obviously. Moreover, Williams was wearing the boots hed worn the night of Lloyds disappearance, which were matched to footprints found in the snow outside her house. He writes that Det.-Sgt. consistent with a Pathfinder. Hidden in the basement ceiling of the Ottawa house were two computer hard-drives containing expertly concealed records of Williamss activities as a sexual predator over a two-year period. The statement is a reminder that her good friend was "kidnapped, raped, tortured and murdered" by Williams and that the "disclosure of these details was a traumatic nightmare.". ., What they also do to try and identify the type of vehicle is they look at what they call the wheelbase width, the officer told him, explaining that various makes and models have different measurements. Smyth has also taught forensic interviewing and forensic behavioural science at Toronto's Seneca College. More aptly described as an enclosed cubicle, the video room, as police call it, was probably not much bigger than the walk-in bedroom closet at the colonels Ottawa home. He really didnt understand himself any better than the detective did. Rafferty has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder, sexual assault causing bodily harm and abduction. Thats all been explained to us by the medical evidence and the experts and the CSI people who do their job and they do it very well, okay? Jim Smyth, a veteran investigator, is the other man seen in the video. The detective returned with a cup of water for Williams and some maps from Google that he had printed off showing the Tweed area. Canada ends evacuation flights from Sudan over 'deteriorating security situation', Royal Family unveils sneak peek of King Charles III and Queen Camillas coronation robes, Widening manhunt for Texas gunman slowed by 'zero leads', Tom Mulcair: Should Trudeau lead the Liberals against Poilievre? No doubt youll sleep a bit easier now that Ive been caught. They knew that if they did not have the search warrants and were not prepared to execute them while he was undergoing questioning, their suspect would likely have walked from the roomand possibly destroyed any evidence before they had the opportunity to find it. Now Im struggling with how upset my wife is right now.. He asked the colonel about an order that had allegedly been given at the base advising subordinates that they did not have to speak to the police and to seek legal counsel before they did so. Star Newspapers Limited and/or its licensors. Box 500 Station A Toronto, ON Canada, M5W 1E6. The detective explained how DNA profiling had advanced so much that only a tiny sample was now required to determine a match. When search suggestions are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. He offered Williams another chance to explain how or why his DNA could have gotten inside any of the victims homes. John Flynn and Terry Lange. But now Detective-Sergeant Smyths sly charm and relentless pursuit of confessions have derailed a major prosecution, leading a judge to rule a suspected murderers admission of guilt was involuntary and possibly false, and therefore inadmissible. "The non-verbals are ringing loud and clear on this one. His uniform was burned, and his decorations were destroyed. Get email updates from your favourite authors. At some point he had gone back and scratched out The moment and written, Immediately before over top of it.]. Straight shooter Sgt. Theres no issue about what happened. First, Williams was told that he was not under any obligation to talk to the officer. In December 2011, it was announced that Smyth was assigned to the criminal behavioural analysis section of the Ontario Provincial Police and is the unit coordinator for the four-member polygraph unit. [4] When it comes to police interrogations, the law in Canada varies significantly from its American cousin. Thats because the law considers me to be what we refer to as a person in authority. . The off-duty colonel removed his bright yellow jacket, draped it over the back of the chair, and placed his black leather gloves on the desktop before sitting down. You and your family are in our thoughts and prayers. A broad grin stretched across Williamss face as he leaned forward, unfolded his arms, and put his hands on his knees. Your opportunity to take some control here. I hope so, Williams mumbled, his face projecting an unspoken arrogance, as though he was trying to keep from smiling. He sat up and crossed his arms as he quietly contemplated his next step. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events. She was in the woods, behind a rock on the east side of Cary Road, forty feet from the roadway and exactly 0.7 kilometers south of East Hungerford Road. . In June 1997 he began working with the OPP, moving to the behavioural sciences section of the force in 2000. I wasn't snooping and I didn't examine the labels," Mr. Farquhar said. But karma and society would soon punish Williams for his crude and horrifying actions. He stood staring at the floor as the detective asked two questions that would soon be on the minds of many people. Russell Williams Case. When he finally left, he took underwear as trophies. He realized that there would be significant consequences for his actions, so his decision had to be a calculated and informed one. Well, what would you be willing to give me today to help me move past you in this investigation? he asked. . [2] Instead, the interviewer would strive to appear confident yet relaxed, and at least as calm as the suspect.[3]. He was subsequently kept under 24-hour watch. ., So is there anything you can remember doing that, you know, would cause you to drive off the road at that section of the roadway?, No. The verbal struggle continued for over twenty minutes. presentation-ready copies of Toronto Star content for distribution He broke into her house on Highway 37 near Belleville, Ontario, at about 1:00 a.m. on 29 January, and found Lloyd asleep. Russ, maybe this would help. I had sort of a stomach flu, he said. . . That earlier letter had read: I would like to take this opportunity on behalf of the men and women of 8 Wing Trenton to express my sincere condolences on the tragic death of your daughter. Together they would compare notes and plan their next course of action before Smyth returned to the video room. Williamss head continued to bob in a rapid succession of gentle nods, his forehead growing increasingly flush from the stress he was under. . He smiled and chuckled as he told the officer how he then drove back home, vacuumed his carpets, and wiped the tiled floors clean. There are loved ones," who she wished Seelig and those supporting the production thought about "when we think about crime and we think about these salacious stories. However, 15 of the 25 Orleans families whose homes were broken into reported the crimes to the Ottawa Police Department. During the burglaries Williams took photographs of female undergarments spread out on a bed, and of himself wearing brassieres and panties. The director calls it a documentary on stage. Do you remember what you wouldve done that evening to go to Ottawa for that meeting? Let us never forget their bravery and . Readers using BlackBerries and iPhones can The conversation soon took another dramatic shift. He shook his head. In June 1997 he began working with the OPP, moving to the behavioural sciences section of the force in. At the time, he had murdered two young women by suffocation, beaten and tied up two of his neighbours before photographing them naked, and stolen about 500 items of lingerie and clothing from the closets of unsuspecting women. When he returned later that same evening, he drove straight back to Ottawa to help his wife with some unpacking, since he had the Monday off work. Jim Munsterman, Alicia Lampert and Bill Holmes. Previously, Ed was a Detective Constable at Government of Ontario Read More Ed Johnson's Phone Number and Email Last Update 3/6/2023 5:40 AM Email e***@opp.ca Engage via Email Contact Number (905) ***-**** Engage via Phone Smyth later made attempts to gain an understanding of the psychology behind his quickly escalating attacks. . Retired OPP investigator Dave Perry said it is compelling to watch as Smyth calmly presses Williams on his links to the crimes. "He just thought he was going to outsmart everybody else and talk his way right out of it," Mendelson told CTV Toronto after viewing the video of the confession. He pleaded guiltyto two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Lloyd and Cpl. However, whether or not Williamss confession was actually required for conviction, considering the vast amount of physical evidence that was seized from his homes, will remain a matter of legal conjecture. I know she loved you very muchshe told me so, again and again. Is Jessica somewhere we can find her easily? he asked calmly. I prefer Law & Order, but I do watch CSIoccasionally, Williams said. ", Eventually, Williams reveals that he is concerned about the fact the OPP will soon be "tearing apart my wife's brand new house. Dafoe grew up with the 27-year-old Belleville resident, who was killed in 2010 by the former commander of CFB Trenton in eastern Ontario. Ottawa Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on. He was read his formal rights to counsel and caution, and given a further opportunity to consult with a lawyer, which he declined.
Sonicwall Netextender Account Is Already In Use,
Sdsu College Of Sciences Dean's List Spring 2020,
Why Is Madame Maxime Taller Than Hagrid,
Lilith In Aries Celebs,
How Did Hogan's Heroes Explain Kinch Leave,
Articles D